There is growing evidence that environmental chemicals can disrupt endocrine systems. Most evidence originates from studies on reproductive organs. However, there is also suspicion that thyroid homeostasis may be disrupted. Several groups of chemicals have potential for thyroid disruption. There is substantial evidence that polychlorinated biphenyls, dioxins and furans cause hypothyroidism in exposed animals and that environmentally occurring doses affect human thyroid homeostasis. Similarly, flame retardants reduce peripheral thyroid hormone (TH) levels in rodents, but human studies are scarce. Studies also indicate thyroid-disruptive properties of phthalates, but the effect of certain phthalates seems to be stimulative on TH production, contrary to most other groups of chemicals. Thyroid disruption may be caused by a variety of mechanisms, as different chemicals interfere with the hypothalamic–pituitary–thyroid axis at different levels. Mechanisms of action may involve the sodium–iodide symporter, thyroid peroxidase enzyme, receptors for THs or TSH, transport proteins or cellular uptake mechanisms. The peripheral metabolism of the THs can be affected through effects on iodothyronine deiodinases or hepatic enzymes. Even small changes in thyroid homeostasis may adversely affect human health, and especially fetal neurological development may be vulnerable. It is therefore urgent to clarify whether the animal data showing effects of chemicals on thyroid function can be extended to humans.
Over the past decade there has been an increasing focus on the effects of synthetic chemicals on human endocrine systems – especially on effects related to androgen and estrogen homeostasis. However, there is increasing evidence from animal and in vitro studies that also the thyroid is vulnerable to endocrine-disrupting effects.
Environmental chemicals may interfere with thyroid homeostasis through many mechanisms of action, i.e. at the receptor level, in binding to transport proteins, in cellular uptake mechanisms or in modifying the metabolism of thyroid hormones (THs) (Fig. 1). Several environmental chemicals have a high degree of structural resemblance to the THs thyroxine (T4) and triiodothyronine (T3), and therefore interfere with binding of THs to receptors or transport proteins. This, in turn, may lead to subclinical hypothyroidism, which in adults is often diagnosed only by chance because of subtle symptoms. However, growth and development in fetal life and childhood is highly dependent on normal levels of THs. Particularly during gestation, normal levels of THs are crucial for the development of the central nervous system. This critical phase may be vulnerable to even subtle effects of synthetic chemicals on fetal and maternal TH levels. Such developmental deficiencies may not be identifiable until later in life (1).
Perchlorate is an example of a chemical with well known antithyroidal effects, which has been exploited in diagnosis and treatment of thyrotoxicosis (2). It has therefore been of concern that perchlorate is found in drinking water (3). A study of workers in an ammonium perchlorate production plant found a significant decrease in thyroid gland iodine uptake related to presence at work (4). However, human studies are contradictory concerning the effect of environmentally occurring levels of perchlorate on neonatal thyroid function (5–7).
Here we present a review of the literature on the impact of endocrine disrupters on thyroid function –with a focus on human health and especially fetal vulnerability.
Polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs)
PCBs comprise 209 highly persistent, distinct congeners that accumulate in lipid tissues. Their hydroxylated metabolites are also biologically active. PCBs and especially the hydroxylated metabolites have a high degree of structural resemblance to T4. The effect of PCB exposure on peripheral TH levels is well documented by studies in laboratory animals. One of the most consistent findings is that PCB exposure decreases the levels of circulating THs, especially T4 (8–10). Histopathological changes of the thyroid indicative of hyperactivity were found after both oral and s.c. exposure (10, 11). Monkeys exposed orally to PCB for 18–23 weeks showed significant dose-dependent reduction of T4, free T4 (FT4), total T3 (TT3) and increase in thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH) as well as histopathological changes of the thyroid compatible with induced hypothyroidism (12). There is substantial evidence that perinatal PCB exposure decreases THs in rat pups (13–21). Also injection of PCBs into chicken eggs from early gestation resulted in a severe decrease of the TH peak late in gestation, accompanied by a considerable delay in the timing of hatching (22, 23).
PCBs are metabolized to hydroxylated PCB compounds (OH-PCBs), which in rodents can accumulate in the fetal compartment. In pregnant rats exposed to 4-OH-CB107, accumulation of the metabolite was found in fetal liver, brain and plasma, and total T4 (TT4) in both maternal and fetal blood samples was decreased. Furthermore, FT4 was significantly decreased and TSH increased in the fetus. The levels of T4 in fetal forebrain were similarly decreased and deiodination of T4 to T3 was increased (18). A study of PCB77 showed a similar reduction of fetal peripheral THs and an accumulation of the hydroxylated metabolite of this congener in the fetal compartment in mice (15). Similar relationships between thyroid function and the concentration of PCBs in plasma are reported from wildlife animals. Significant decreases of T3 and/or T4 were found in sea lions (24), polar bears (25) and seals (26, 27), and histopathological changes of thyroid glands related to exposure level were found in jungle crows (28) and cormorants (29).
Multiple studies of PCB exposure and effects have been carried out in human populations, the majority of which raise concern that environmental levels of PCBs may alter thyroid homeostasis. In adults, adolescents and children (Table 1) from highly PCB-exposed areas the concentration of PCB in blood samples correlated negatively to levels of circulating peripheral THs (30, 31). A few studies also demonstrated a positive correlation between PCB exposure and TSH (32, 33). In contrast, other studies found no associations between PCBs and THs in serum (34, 35). The thyroid volume is another endpoint for thyroid function, which is rarely used in human toxicological studies. In adults from a PCB-polluted area the thyroid volume assessed by ultrasound was found to be significantly larger than in ‘non-exposed’ subjects. The highest thyroid volumes were clustered among 5% of subjects (n = 23) with PCB levels above 10 000 ng/g lipids (36).
Perinatal exposure to PCBs may be the most important for chronic effects. Measurements of PCBs in cord blood were not associated with infant THs (37–39). However, measurements of PCBs in maternal blood during pregnancy showed negative correlations to peripheral maternal THs and positive correlations to TSH (39). Similarly, most studies of PCB content in breast milk did not demonstrate significant associations with infant peripheral TH levels (40–42), although one study found significant positive correlation to TSH in the infants as well as significant negative correlations to maternal TT3 and TT4 (40). These changes in THs were within normal reference ranges. A study of boys prenatally exposed to high doses of PCBs and polychlorinated dibenzo-p-furans (PCDFs) showed no differences in thyroid function compared with a control group (43). In conclusion, human and wildlife observations point towards subtle, but significant, effects of low-dose PCB exposure on human thyroid function.
Polychlorinated dibenzo-p-dioxins (PCDDs) and furans (PCDFs) are widespread, persistent and highly toxic environmental pollutants from industrial burning processes or production of herbicides. 2,3,7,8-tetra-chloro-dibenzo-p-dioxin (TCDD) is the prototype for this class of chemicals and the most toxic among PCDD/F congeners.
TCDD given to pregnant rats is transferred to their offspring via transplacental and lactational routes (44). A single dose of TCDD in rats dose-dependently decreased T4 and FT4 (45) and increased TSH (46). In offspring a single dose of TCDD to the dam during gestation was correlated to decreased T4 and to a 2-fold increase in TSH (in male offspring) as well as hyperplasia of the thyroid gland (47). Human studies are scarce, but in a large study of Vietnam war veterans, the group with the highest exposure to TCDD showed a significant increase in TSH levels (48).
The group of flame retardants contains different chemicals such as tetrabromobisphenol A (TBBPA), polybrominated diphenyl ethers (PBDEs) and polybrominated biphenyls. TBBPA and PBDEs show even closer structural relationship to T4 than PCBs. PBDEs are extensively used as flame retardants in plastics, paints, electrical components and synthetic textiles. TBBPA is a halogenated derivative of bisphenol A (BPA) and is widely used as a flame retardant in electrical equipment such as televisions, computers, copying machines, video displays and laser printers. TBBPA is generally regarded a safe flame retardant because it is not readily accumulated in the environment, nor is it highly toxic.
In rodent studies, PBDEs reduced the circulating levels of THs. The commercial PBDE mixture DE-71 decreased the levels of circulating THs and induced the activity of the hepatic enzymes uridinediphosphate-glucuronosyl-transferase (UDPGT), ethoxyresorufin-o-deethylase (EROD) and pentoxyresorufin-o-deethylase (PROD) (49–51). High doses of DE-71 also resulted in histopathological changes such as increased follicular epithelial height and colloid depletion, indicative of a hypothyroid state. Another commercial mixture, Bromkal, as well as the pure congener DE-47 decreased FT4 and TT4 levels and induced microsomal enzyme activities (EROD, methoxyresorufin-o-deethylase (MROD), PROD) (9), whereas the pure pentabrominated congener BDE-99 was a less potent reducer of TH levels when administered at equimolar doses (52). No histopathological changes were observed after treatment with DE-47, but plasma binding of T4 was significantly reduced after high dose of DE-47 (10). Lower-brominated BDE congeners were more potent plasma T4 reducers than mixtures containing higher-brominated congeners (50). In fish, TT4 was decreased after exposure to PBDE (53). Perinatal maternal exposure of rats to different mixtures and congeners of PBDE reduced THs pre-and postnatally in both dams and fetuses (54). Similarly, exposure of kestrels before and after hatching to different PBDE congeners decreased T4 levels in the offspring (55). TBBPA exhibited antithyroidal effects by decreasing the rate of tail shortening in tadpole metamorphosis (56). Further studies of TBBPA are mainly in vitro and described in details below.
Few human studies exist regarding flame retardants and thyroid function. Eleven workers in an electronic recycling facility were followed over 1.5 years. Levels of PBDE were fluctuating during the study and there was a trend towards increasing T4 over time. Changes were small and not significant, and as such not conclusive (57). In 110 men exposed through Baltic fish consumption, plasma levels of persistent organohalogens were measured and showed among multiple correlations a significant negative association between TSH and the PBDE BDE-47 (34). In a study of perinatal exposure levels, THs and six congeners of PBDE were measured in 12 pairs of maternal and cord blood. There was no apparent correlation between serum PBDEs and TH levels, which may be due to a very small sample size (58).
Thus, our current knowledge on the effect of flame retardants on human thyroid function is very limited.
Phenols: nonylphenol (NP), pentachlorophenol (PCP) and BPA
NP and octaphenol are industrial additives used in a wide variety of detergents, plastics and pesticides. NP may be one of the more critical compounds due to its toxicity, persistence and estrogenic effects. PCP has been extensively used as a biocide and wood preservative in the timber industry and as an antifungal agent in the leather industry. Furthermore, PCP is the primary metabolite of the pesticide hexachlorobenzene (HCB), which is described in detail below. BPA is used to manufacture polycarbonate and numerous plastic products including compact discs, foodcan linings, adhesives, powder paints and dental sealants. BPA is rapidly glucuronidated in rats and humans.
Exposure of rats to NP increased TSH dose-dependently (59), but no consistent effects on peripheral hormones were found (59, 60). Another rat study showed increased levels of T3 and T4, but no change in TSH in ovariectomized rats. This pattern was not consistent with in vitro studies of protein extracts showing NP to inhibit thyroperoxidase (TPO) activity (61). PCP also decreased T4 levels in ewes (62, 63). In fish and tadpoles, NP may have an impact on development as TH levels were clearly decreased (64) as well as the rate of metamorphic progression and tail resorption in bullfrog tadpoles (65).
Rats exposed to BPA exhibited increased weight of the thyroid, but no histopathological changes (66). No significant effects on TH levels were found in either polecats (67) or field voles (68) after BPA exposure. However, a positive correlation between increasing BPA and activity of UDPGT was found – UDPGT catalyzes the conjugation of various substances to glucuronic acid, and an increasing activity may lead to faster metabolism of THs. BPA blocked T3-induced resorption of tail segments in larvae in vitro and decelerated T4-induced metamorphic changes of tadpoles in vivo (69). BPA fed to pregnant rats was associated with significant increase of TT4 at postnatal day 15 in the pups (70).
Human literature on these compounds is very sparse. In human newborns, PCP in cord plasma was negatively correlated to T3, FT4 and T4-binding globulin (TBG) (71). These results suggest that PCP may alter TH levels in newborns and consequently may lead to adverse neurodevelopmental defects.
Phthalates are widely used as plastic emollients and the amount used globally is rising. Exposure to phthalates is inevitable, but for certain groups such as hospitalized neonates exposure may be massive. The exposure to phthalates through necessary medical devices such as feeding tubes is correlated to the urinary content of mono(2-ethylexyl)phthalate (72), and such intensive exposure at a potentially vulnerable point of development may cause permanent damage, despite the fast metabolism of phthalates. Expert panel reports reviewed reproductive and developmental effects of five di-phthalates (di-isodecyl phthalate (DIDP), di-n-octyl phthalate (DnOP), di-n-hexyl phthalate (DnHP), di-isononyl phthalate and di(2-ethylhexyl) phthalate (DEHP)). As relatively few studies have been focusing on thyroid-disrupting effects, firm conclusions on this aspect could not be drawn (73–79).
Rodent studies found histopathological changes in the thyroid of rats after exposure to DEHP, DnOP and DnHP, corresponding to hyperactivity of the thyroid (80–84). Long-term treatment with high doses of DEHP resulted in basophilic deposits in the colloid and enlargement of the lysosomes (80). The levels of circulating THs were not affected after oral exposure of rats to DEHP (85), whereas i.v. exposure in doses corresponding to levels of DEHP solubilized in blood bags for human transfusions resulted in a significant increase in serum T3 and T4, which returned to normal after 7 days (86). The thyroid glands examined in this study showed initial reactive hyperplasia. In contrast di-n-butyl phthalate (DBP) decreased T3 and T4 in rats in a dose-dependent manner (87).
Only few studies exist on the effects of phthalates on human thyroid function. A follow-up examination of 19 adolescents, who were exposed to large amounts of DEHP due to invasive treatment in the neonatal period (extra-corporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO)), showed normal levels of THs (88). These results may not be representative, as DEHP exposure through ECMO treatment is extremely high (89), but of short duration. Furthermore, changes in TH levels as a result of exposure to environmental chemicals may be transient. They may nonetheless have permanent effects on the development of the central nervous system, if changes occur in a critical developmental phase.
Other groups of chemicals with potential effects on the thyroid are parabens and pesticides, of which the latter are a large and inhomogeneous group of compounds.
Parabens are widely used as preservatives in food, cosmetics and pharmaceutical products. Recent studies suggest that parabens possess estrogenic potential, but no studies have focused on thyroid toxicity (90). Methylparaben seemed to have a weak intrinsic antithyroid activity in vitro by dose-dependently inhibiting iodide organification (91).
Among many different pesticides, the thyroid-disrupting effects of dichlorodiphenyltrichloroethane (DDT) and HCB are the most studied. DDT exposure of birds decreased T4 (92) or increased thyroid weight and reduced colloid content of the follicles (93). However, other studies found no measurable thyroid effects (94). Blubber concentration of DDT correlated negatively to TT3 and free T3 in seals (26, 27), whereas a study of sea-gulls showed no correlations with THs (95).
HCB is metabolized to PCP, which has endocrine-disrupting abilities. Multiple studies in laboratory animals confirm the negative correlation between HCB and T4 (96–100), and in some studies also T3 (101, 102). The metabolites of HCB, PCP and tetrachlorohydroquinone, had even stronger effects than the parent compounds (103). Prenatal HCB exposure of rats reduced serum levels of T4 and FT4 in pups and increased T4-UDPGT and type II 5′deiodinase (5′DII) in the brain (98). This indicated an increased peripheral T4 metabolism, which may represent local hypothyroidism in the fetal brain, where 5′DII is responsible for deiodination of T4 to the biologically active T3. Wildlife observations of HCB exposure showed negative correlations to the ratio TT4/FT4 in polar bears (25), and to T4 and T4/T3 ratio in gulls (95). A study of seals found no associations of THs to HCB (27). An excess ratio of enlarged thyroid was found among people accidentally exposed to high levels of HCB (104), and several studies of adults have shown negative associations between HCB and serum levels of T4 (33, 35, 105) or T3 (39), but not TSH or free hormones (105). In infants, no correlations between the concentration of HCB and THs in cord blood were found (39). Thus, evidence of thyroid-disruptive properties of DDT and HCB is concerning.
Many other pesticides are currently used, and reports on their thyroid-disrupting effects are emerging, e.g. methoxychlor (106, 107), chlordane (26, 108) and endosulfan (109). Humans may be exposed to mixtures of these compounds and numerous others, which makes a prediction of expected health effects very difficult. Chemicals may have different effects on the thyroid axis or act synergistically as has been shown in rats exposed to a mixture of PCBs, PCDDs and PBDEs, which resulted in a dose-dependent decrease of TT4 (110).
Mechanisms of action
Until recent years the estimation of antithyroidal effects of environmental chemicals has mainly relied on measures of circulating hormone levels, thyroid size or histopathology, but over the last 10 years, additional endpoints have been developed. Intra-thyroidal T4 content, gene transcription activity and cellular growth appear to be more sensitive endpoints when assessing the significance of endocrine disruption from various chemicals. A well established example is perchlorate, which in small amounts does not alter plasma hormone levels, but diminishes thyroid gland T4 content (111–113), supporting the observation from in vitro studies of an inhibition of sodium–iodide symporter (NIS) (114). Thus, endocrine-disrupting chemicals present in small amounts in the environment may not cause overt changes of hormone levels in animals and humans, but may nonetheless alter the hormonal homeostasis.
Perchlorate compromises iodine uptake to the thyroid follicular cells by inhibiting the NIS (114) (Fig. 2). In contrast, phthalates such as DIDP, butyl benzyl phthalate (BBP) and DnOP increased the activity of the NIS and enhanced NIS mRNA expression (115). TPO activity was inhibited in vitro by NP (61). The activity of the thyroid gland is stimulated by TSH and may thus be altered by environmental chemicals affecting the function of the TSH receptor. DDT and the PCB mixture Aroclor 1254 interfered in vitro with post-receptor signaling by inhibition of the adenylate cyclase activity and cAMP production (116).
Halogenated aromatic hydrocarbons structurally resemble THs and may therefore compete with binding to the TH receptors and transport proteins, possibly interfering with TH transport and metabolism. PCBs (18, 117), flame retardants (118), phenol compounds (119, 120) and phthalates (121) competitively bound to transthyretin (TTR). Metabolites and derivatives of PCBs, several brominated flame retardants and phenol compounds had remarkably stronger binding affinity than their parent compounds, indicating an important role for hydroxylation and halogenation in thyroid toxicity (118). In contrast to the interference with TTR, no environmental chemicals have been demonstrated to compete with THs for binding to TBG or albumin with significant strength (122, 123).
Competitive binding of environmental chemicals to TH transport proteins may result in increased bioavailibility of endogenous THs. The investigation of this mechanism of action is restrained by interspecies differences, as TTR is the principal transport protein in rodents and TBG in humans. It is unlikely that enough T4 could be displaced from TTR to be toxic in adult humans (117). However, TTR is the major TH transport protein in the human brain, presumably playing an essential role in the determination of FT4 levels in the extracellular compartment, which is independent of the T4 homeostasis in the body. Furthermore, TTR may mediate the delivery of T4 across the blood–brain barrier and the maternal to fetal transport through the placenta. Thus, environmental chemicals bound to TTR may be transported to the fetal compartment and fetal brain, and be able to decrease fetal brain T4 levels (124).
Bioavailibility of THs to the nuclear TH receptors may become compromised as THs are probably actively transported across the cell surface via membrane bound transporters. Several environmental chemicals, including DBP and BBP inhibited [125I]T3 uptake in red blood cells from bullfrog tadpoles (125).
Environmental chemicals can change TH-stimulated gene transcription, but it is still not clear through which mechanisms these changes are induced.
T3-mediated gene activation through thyroid receptor alfa-1 (TRalfa1) and TRbeta was dose-dependently suppressed by BPA and expression of T3-suppressed genes was upregulated by BPA. Thus, BPA acted as an antagonist to T3 (126). Maternal exposure to BPA in rats increased the expression of TH-responsive gene neurogranin in the hippocampus of the pups. This led to speculations that BPA may antagonize the feedback through TRbeta, but act as an agonist at TRalfa and thus upregulate TH-responsive genes (70). However, other studies found no effect of BPA on expression of T3-mediated reporter genes in a hamster ovary cell line (127) and pituitary cell line (128). BPA was a weak ligand for the TR (126), but the derivatives TBBPA and tetrachlorobisphenol competed for binding to the receptor (56).
PCBs also alter the expression of TH-responsive genes. PCBs acted as antagonists by partial dissociation of TR/retinoid X receptor heterodimer complex from the TH response element (TRE) (129). OH-PCBs inhibited the binding of T3 to the TR (130), but other studies found that the human TRbeta had very low affinity for OH-PCBs, DDT and its metabolites and that other organochlorine pesticides did not compete for the receptor (131). Thus, the competitive binding of some environmental chemicals appears to be both receptor-specific and compound-specific. Increased gene expression in the fetal rat brain after maternal exposure to PCBs included neuroendocrine-specific protein A, neurogranin, myelin basic protein, and the transcription factors oct-1 and hairy enhancer of split (132–134), RC3/neurogranin and myelin basic protein in pups of PCB-treated dams (134). In a study of brain protein extracts from PCB-treated chicken embryos 17 of 109 differentially expressed proteins differed with PCB treatment (135). Malic enzyme (ME) gene expression is regulated mainly by THs and was increased by exposure to HCB, probably through still unidentified nuclear proteins that bind to the TRE of the ME promoter (136).
Seiwa et al. examined the effect of BPA on oligodendrocyte precursor cell (OPC) differentiation on myelin basic protein, which is a major myelin component, and 2,3-cyclic nucleotide 3-phosphodiesterase expression. TRbeta1-levels in OPCs and oligodendrocytes decreased significantly after BPA treatment for 48 h, suggesting a suppression of T3-induced differentiation of OPCs. Expression of TRalfa1 was not affected (137). Dicyclo-hexyl phthalate, BBP and PCP inhibited the expression of the TRbeta gene (138).
Oligodendrocyte development and myelination are under TH control, as well as the extension of Purkinje cell dendrites, which is essential for normal neuronal circuit formation (synaptogenesis) and subsequent behavioral functions. In a study of perinatal exposure, PCB affected the development of white matter in rat pups by mimicking some, but not all, of the effects of hypothyroidism on white matter, indicating that PCB may partly affect the neurological development through thyroid disruption (139). These effects may be congener-specific as another study showed a single PCB congener to enhance the effect of T3 by increasing the formation of oligodendrocytes (140). PCBs also caused abnormal development of Purkinje cell dendrites (141).
Peripheral iodothyronine deiodinases control the conversion of THs in different organs and are thus essential in the regulation of levels of the biologically active T3 by activation of T4 and inactivation of T4 and T3. Type I 5′deiodinase (5′DI) in the liver was decreased in vitro by several environmental chemicals: octyl-methoxycinnamate, 4-methylbenzylidene-camphor (MBC) (61), methoxychlor (142), and a mixture of organochlorines, lead and cadmium (143).
OH-PCBs inhibited TH sulfation (144–146).The sulfotransferase isozymes were also target proteins for inhibition by hydroxylated polyhalogenated aromatic hydrocarbons (PHAHs). OH-PCBs, PCDDs, PCDFs and other halogenated compounds were potent inhibitors of in vitro T2 sulfation (144). TCDD induced UDPGT activity in a dose-dependent manner in both exposed adult rats (46) and in the offspring (47), and decreased the activity of 5′DI in liver and kidney (45). Exposure doses of BPA in polecats (67) and field voles (68) were significantly correlated to the activity of UDPGT. UDPGTs catalyze the conjugation of various substances to glucuronic acid and increasing activity may lead to faster metabolism of the THs. However, in these studies, no significant effects on TH levels were found.
Significance and perspectives
Humans are exposed continuously to a large number of man-made chemicals, many of which are persistent in the environment. Many studies of exposure to various environmental chemicals point towards a subtle disruption of the thyroid axis within normal reference values. The T4/TSH relationship is very unique for each human, and the intra-individual variation of THs is small compared with the population-based reference intervals (147–149). Thus, small changes in thyroid function within the normal reference range may have negative health consequences for the individual. In particular, the human fetus may be vulnerable to subtle changes in the T4 and TSH homeostasis as the fetal turnover of the thyroid store of T4 is very rapid (150). Thus, the fetus may become depleted of T4 more rapidly than adults. Even mild hypothyroidism in the mother or the fetus can result in neonatal neurological and cognitive deficiencies, which may not be measurable until adulthood.
There is evidence that exposure to PHAHs such as PCBs and dioxin may cause cognitive damage in humans (151–153). This effect may be mediated by induction of hypothyroidism, which is known to cause cognitive deficiencies in the fetus/infant.
The literature on thyroid-disrupting effects of individual chemicals is rapidly increasing, as animal exposure studies and in vitro tests reveal a multitude of potential mechanisms of action. For some persistent compounds, such as PCBs, the available evidence is much stronger than for some of the rapidly metabolized chemicals such as phthalates. Although interspecies differences in thyroid homeostasis need to be kept in mind, the evidence from animals should raise concern, especially about exposure of the human infant and fetus to chemicals.
This study was supported by the Danish Medical Research Council (9700909) and the Novo Nordisk Foundation.
Human studies of thyroid effects of PCB. PCBs were measured in blood if not otherwise stated.
|Author||Year||No. of subjects||Effect||Reference|
|aPCB measured in breast milk.|
|Hsu et al.||2005||60 boys||No effects||43|
|Takser et al.||2005||101 mothers 92 cord blood||Mothers: ↓ TT3, ↑ TSH Cord blood: No significant correlations||39|
|Schell et al.||2004||115 adults||↓ FT4, ↓ T4, ↑ TSH||33|
|Bloom et al.||2003||66 adults||No effects||35|
|Ribas-Fito et al.||2003||98 infants||No significant effects (trend toward ↑ TSH)||38|
|Langer et al.||2003||101 adults||Higher thyroid volume in highly exposed subjects||36|
|Persky et al.||2001||229 adults||↓ T4, FTI (females); ↑ T3-uptake (men)||31|
|Matsuura et al.||2001||337 breastfed infantsa||No effects||42|
|Sala et al.||2001||192 (608) adults||No significant effects (trend toward ↑ TSH)||105|
|Hagmar et al.||2001||110 adults (men)||No effects||34|
|Hagmar et al.||2001||182 adults (women)||↓ TT3||30|
|Steuerwald et al.||2000||182 children||No effects||37|
|Longnecker et al.||2000||160 cord blood||No effects||41|
|Osius et al.||1999||320 children||↓ FT3, ↑ TSH||32|
|Koopman-Esseboom et al.||1994||105 mothers and Infantsa||Mothers: ↓ TT3, ↓ TT4 Infants: ↑ TSH (2 weeks and 3 months age)||40|
Mechanisms of action of thyroid-disrupting chemicals.
|Mechanisms of action||Group of chemicals||References|
|Inhibition of the iodide uptake||Perchlorate, phthalates||114, 115|
|Inhibition of the function of the TSH receptor||DDT, PCB||116|
|Binding to transport proteins||PCB, phthalates, phenols, flame retardants, HCB||18, 117–123|
|Cellular uptake of thyroid hormones||Phthalates, chlordanes||125|
|Binding to thyroid hormone receptor and gene expression||PCB, phenols, flame retardants, BPA, HCB||56, 70, 126, 129, 130, 132–137|
|Iodothyronine deiodinases||Methoxychlor, MBC||61, 142, 143|
|Excretion/clearance of thyroid hormones||PCB, dioxin, phenols, flame retardants, HCB, BPA||45–47,67,68,144–146|
BravermanLE, He X, Pino S, Cross M, Magnani B, Lamm SH, Kruse MB, Engel A, Crump KS & Gibbs JP. The effect of perchlorate, thiocyanate, and nitrate on thyroid function in workers exposed to perchlorate long-term. Journal of Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism200590700–706.
KelshMA, Buffler PA, Daaboul JJ, Rutherford GW, Lau EC, Barnard JC, Exuzides AK, Madl AK, Palmer LG & Lorey FW. Primary congenital hypothyroidism, newborn thyroid function, and environmental perchlorate exposure among residents of a Southern California community. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine2003451116–1127.
van der PlasSA, Lutkeschipholt I, Spenkelink B & Brouwer A. Effects of subchronic exposure to complex mixtures of dioxin-like and non-dioxin-like polyhalogenated aromatic compounds on thyroid hormone and vitamin A levels in female Sprague–Dawley rats. Toxicological Sciences20015992–100.
SeoBW, Li MH, Hansen LG, Moore RW, Peterson RE & Schantz SL. Effects of gestational and lactational exposure to coplanar polychlorinated biphenyl (PCB) congeners or 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin (TCDD) on thyroid hormone concentrations in weanling rats. Toxicology Letters199578253–262.
MeertsIA, Assink Y, Cenijn PH, Van Den Berg JH, Weijers BM, Bergman A, Koeman JH & Brouwer A. Placental transfer of a hydroxylated polychlorinated biphenyl and effects on fetal and maternal thyroid hormone homeostasis in the rat. Toxicological Sciences200268361–371.
DonahueDA, Dougherty EJ & Meserve LA. Influence of a combination of two tetrachlorobiphenyl congeners (PCB 47; PCB 77) on thyroid status, choline acetyltransferase (ChAT) activity, and short- and long-term memory in 30-day-old Sprague–Dawley rats. Toxicology200420399–107.
MeertsIA, Lilienthal H, Hoving S, Van Den Berg JH, Weijers BM, Bergman A, Koeman JH & Brouwer A. Developmental exposure to 4-hydroxy-2,3,3′,4′,5-pentachlorobiphenyl (4-OH-CB107): long-term effects on brain development, behavior, and brain stem auditory evoked potentials in rats. Toxicological Sciences200482207–218.
RoelensSA, Beck V, Maervoet J, Aerts G, Reyns GE, Schepens P & Darras VM. The dioxin-like PCB 77 but not the ortho-substituted PCB 153 interferes with chicken embryo thyroid hormone homeostasis and delays hatching. General and Comparative Endocrinology20051431–9.
SkaareJU, Bernhoft A, Wiig O, Norum KR, Haug E, Eide DM & Derocher AE. Relationships between plasma levels of organochlorines, retinol and thyroid hormones from polar bears (Ursus maritimus) at Svalbard. Journal of Toxicology and Environmental Health. Part A200162227–241.
ChibaI, Sakakibara A, Goto Y, Isono T, Yamamoto Y, Iwata H, Tanabe S, Shimazaki K, Akahori F, Kazusaka A & Fujita S. Negative correlation between plasma thyroid hormone levels and chlorinated hydrocarbon levels accumulated in seals from the coast of Hokkaido, Japan. Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry2001201092–1097.
SormoEG, Jussi I, Jussi M, Braathen M, Skaare JU & Jenssen BM. Thyroid hormone status in gray seal (Halichoerus grypus) pups from the Baltic Sea and the Atlantic Ocean in relation to organochlorine pollutants. Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry200524610–616.
KobayashiM, Kashida Y, Yoneda K, Iwata H, Watanabe M, Tanabe S, Fukatsu H, Machida N & Mitsumori K. Thyroid lesions and dioxin accumulation in the livers of jungle crows (Corvus macrorhynchos) in urban and suburban Tokyo. Archives of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology200548424–432.
LangerP, Kocan A, Tajtakova M, Petrik J, Chovancova J, Drobna B, Jursa S, Pavuk M, Koska J, Trnovec T, Sebokova E & Klimes I. Possible effects of polychlorinated biphenyls and organochlorinated pesticides on the thyroid after long-term exposure to heavy environmental pollution. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine200345526–532.
Koopman-EsseboomC, Morse DC, Weisglas-Kuperus N, Lutkeschipholt IJ, Van der Paauw CG, Tuinstra LG, Brouwer A & Sauer PJ. Effects of dioxins and polychlorinated biphenyls on thyroid hormone status of pregnant women and their infants. Pediatric Research199436468–473.
MatsuuraN, Uchiyama T, Tada H, Nakamura Y, Kondo N, Morita M & Fukushi M. Effects of dioxins and polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) on thyroid function in infants born in Japan – the second report from research on environmental health. Chemosphere2001451167–1171.
TomyGT, Palace VP, Halldorson T, Braekevelt E, Danell R, Wautier K, Evans B, Brinkworth L & Fisk AT. Bioaccumulation, biotransformation, and biochemical effects of brominated diphenyl ethers in juvenile lake trout (Salvelinus namaycush). Environmental Science and Technology2004381496–1504.
FernieKJ, Shutt JL, Mayne G, Hoffman D, Letcher RJ, Drouillard KG & Ritchie IJ. Exposure to polybrominated diphenyl ethers (PBDEs): changes in thyroid, vitamin A, glutathione homeostasis, and oxidative stress in American kestrels (Falco sparverius). Toxicological Sciences200588375–383.
KitamuraS, Kato T, Iida M, Jinno N, Suzuki T, Ohta S, Fujimoto N, Hanada H, Kashiwagi K & Kashiwagi A. Anti-thyroid hormonal activity of tetrabromobisphenol A, a flame retardant, and related compounds: Affinity to the mammalian thyroid hormone receptor, and effect on tadpole metamorphosis. Life Sciences2005761589–1601.
JulanderA, Karlsson M, Hagstrom K, Ohlson CG, Engwall M, Bryngelsson IL, Westberg H & van Bavel B. Polybrominated diphenyl ethers – plasma levels and thyroid status of workers at an electronic recycling facility. International Archives of Occupational and Environmental Health200578584–592.
SchmutzlerC, Hamann I, Hofmann PJ, Kovacs G, Stemmler L, Mentrup B, Schomburg L, Ambrugger P, Gruters A, Seidlova-Wuttke D, Jarry H, Wuttke W & Kohrle J. Endocrine active compounds affect thyrotropin and thyroid hormone levels in serum as well as endpoints of thyroid hormone action in liver, heart and kidney. Toxicology200420595–102.
GreenR, Hauser R, Calafat AM, Weuve J, Schettler T, Ringer S, Huttner K & Hu H. Use of di(2-ethylhexyl) phthalate-containing medical products and urinary levels of mono(2-ethylhexyl) phthalate in neonatal intensive care unit infants. Environmental Health Perspectives20051131222–1225.
KavlockR, Boekelheide K, Chapin R, Cunningham M, Faustman E, Foster P, Golub M, Henderson R, Hinberg I, Little R, Seed J, Shea K, Tabacova S, Tyl R, Williams P & Zacharewski T. NTP Center for the Evaluation of Risks to Human Reproduction: phthalates expert panel report on the reproductive and developmental toxicity of di-isodecyl phthalate. Reproductive Toxicology200216655–678.
KavlockR, Boekelheide K, Chapin R, Cunningham M, Faustman E, Foster P, Golub M, Henderson R, Hinberg I, Little R, Seed J, Shea K, Tabacova S, Tyl R, Williams P & Zacharewski T. NTP Center for the Evaluation of Risks to Human Reproduction: phthalates expert panel report on the reproductive and developmental toxicity of di-n-butyl phthalate. Reproductive Toxicology200216489–527.
KavlockR, Boekelheide K, Chapin R, Cunningham M, Faustman E, Foster P, Golub M, Henderson R, Hinberg I, Little R, Seed J, Shea K, Tabacova S, Tyl R, Williams P & Zacharewski T. NTP Center for the Evaluation of Risks to Human Reproduction: phthalates expert panel report on the reproductive and developmental toxicity of butyl benzyl phthalate. Reproductive Toxicology200216453–487.
KavlockR, Boekelheide K, Chapin R, Cunningham M, Faustman E, Foster P, Golub M, Henderson R, Hinberg I, Little R, Seed J, Shea K, Tabacova S, Tyl R, Williams P & Zacharewski T. NTP Center for the Evaluation of Risks to Human Reproduction: phthalates expert panel report on the reproductive and developmental toxicity of di-n-octyl phthalate. Reproductive Toxicology200216721–734.
KavlockR, Boekelheide K, Chapin R, Cunningham M, Faustman E, Foster P, Golub M, Henderson R, Hinberg I, Little R, Seed J, Shea K, Tabacova S, Tyl R, Williams P & Zacharewski T. NTP Center for the Evaluation of Risks to Human Reproduction: phthalates expert panel report on the reproductive and developmental toxicity of di-n-hexyl phthalate. Reproductive Toxicology200216709–719.
KavlockR, Boekelheide K, Chapin R, Cunningham M, Faustman E, Foster P, Golub M, Henderson R, Hinberg I, Little R, Seed J, Shea K, Tabacova S, Tyl R, Williams P & Zacharewski T. NTP Center for the Evaluation of Risks to Human Reproduction: phthalates expert panel report on the reproductive and developmental toxicity of di-isononyl phthalate. Reproductive Toxicology200216679–708.
KavlockR, Boekelheide K, Chapin R, Cunningham M, Faustman E, Foster P, Golub M, Henderson R, Hinberg I, Little R, Seed J, Shea K, Tabacova S, Tyl R, Williams P & Zacharewski T. NTP Center for the Evaluation of Risks to Human Reproduction: phthalates expert panel report on the reproductive and developmental toxicity of di(2-ethylhexyl) phthalate. Reproductive Toxicology200216529–653.
ScollonEJ, Carr JA & Cobb GP. The effect of flight, fasting and p,p′-DDT on thyroid hormones and corticosterone in Gambel’s white-crowned sparrow, Zonotrichia leucophrys gambelli. Comparative Biochemistry and Physiology. Toxicology and Pharmacology2004137179–189.
DesaulniersD, Cooke GM, Leingartner K, Soumano K, Cole J, Yang J, Wade M & Yagminas A. Effects of postnatal exposure to a mixture of polychlorinated biphenyls, p,p′dichlorodiphenyltrichloroethane, and p-p′-dichlorodiphenyldichloroethene in prepubertal and adult female Sprague–Dawley rats. International Journal of Toxicology200524111–127.
MorseDC, Groen D, Veerman M, van Amerongen CJ, Koeter HB, Smits van Prooije AE, Visser TJ, Koeman JH & Brouwer A. Interference of polychlorinated biphenyls in hepatic and brain thyroid hormone metabolism in fetal and neonatal rats. Toxicology and Applied Pharmacology199312227–33.
den BestenC, Bennik MH, Bruggeman I, Schielen P, Kuper F, Brouwer A, Koeman JH, Vos JG & van Bladeren PJ. The role of oxidative metabolism in hexachlorobenzene-induced porphyria and thyroid hormone homeostasis: a comparison with pentachlorobenzene in a 13-week feeding study. Toxicology and Applied Pharmacology1993119181–194.
SalaM, Sunyer J, Herrero C, To-Figueras J & Grimalt J. Association between serum concentrations of hexachlorobenzene and polychlorobiphenyls with thyroid hormone and liver enzymes in a sample of the general population. Occupational and Environmental Medicine200158172–177.
TonaccheraM, Pinchera A, Dimida A, Ferrarini E, Agretti P, Vitti P, Santini F, Crump K & Gibbs J. Relative potencies and additivity of perchlorate, thiocyanate, nitrate, and iodide on the inhibition of radioactive iodide uptake by the human sodium iodide symporter. Thyroid2004141012–1019.
SantiniF, Vitti P, Ceccarini G, Mammoli C, Rosellini V, Pelosini C, Marsili A, Tonacchera M, Agretti P, Santoni T, Chiovato L & Pinchera A. In vitro assay of thyroid disruptors affecting TSH-stimulated adenylate cyclase activity. Journal of Endocrinological Investigation200326950–955.
PurkeyHE, Palaninathan SK, Kent KC, Smith C, Safe SH, Sacchettini JC & Kelly JW. Hydroxylated polychlorinated biphenyls selectively bind transthyretin in blood and inhibit amyloidogenesis: rationalizing rodent PCB toxicity. Chemistry and Biology2004111719–1728.
YamauchiK, Ishihara A, Fukazawa H & Terao Y. Competitive interactions of chlorinated phenol compounds with 3,3′,5-triiodothyronine binding to transthyretin: detection of possible thyroid-disrupting chemicals in environmental waste water. Toxicology and Applied Pharmacology2003187110–117.
GaugerKJ, Kato Y, Haraguchi K, Lehmler HJ, Robertson LW, Bansal R & Zoeller RT. Polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) exert thyroid hormone-like effects in the fetal rat brain but do not bind to thyroid hormone receptors. Environmental Health Perspectives2004112516–523.
ZoellerRT, Dowling AL & Vas AA. Developmental exposure to polychlorinated biphenyls exerts thyroid hormone-like effects on the expression of RC3/neurogranin and myelin basic protein messenger ribonucleic acids in the developing rat brain. Endocrinology2000141181–189.
Loaiza-PerezAI, Seisdedos MT, Kleiman de Pisarev DL, Sancovich HA, Randi AS, Ferramola de Sancovich AM & Santisteban P. Hexachlorobenzene, a dioxin-type compound, increases malic enzyme gene transcription through a mechanism involving the thyroid hormone response element. Endocrinology19991404142–4151.
ZhouLX, Dehal SS, Kupfer D, Morrell S, McKenzie BA, Eccleston ED Jr & Holtzman JL. Cytochrome P450 catalyzed covalent binding of methoxychlor to rat hepatic, microsomal iodothyronine 5′-monodeiodinase, type I: does exposure to methoxychlor disrupt thyroid hormone metabolism? Archives of Biochemistry and Biophysics1995322390–394.
SchuurAG, Legger FF, van Meeteren ME, Moonen MJ, Leeuwen-Bol I, Bergman A, Visser TJ & Brouwer A. In vitro inhibition of thyroid hormone sulfation by hydroxylated metabolites of halogenated aromatic hydrocarbons. Chemical Research in Toxicology1998111075–1081.
WalkowiakJ, Wiener JA, Fastabend A, Heinzow B, Kramer U, Schmidt E, Steingruber HJ, Wundram S & Winneke G. Environmental exposure to polychlorinated biphenyls and quality of the home environment: effects on psychodevelopment in early childhood. Lancet20013581602–1607.