The purpose of this study was to assess changes in the cross-sectional area (CSA) of nervus medianus by ultrasound in newly diagnosed primary hypothyroid patients after thyroxine replacement treatment.
Patients and methods
The cohort comprised 30 patients with newly diagnosed primary autoimmune hypothyroidism. These were subsequently compared with 30 controls, matched for sex, BMI and age. Ultrasound evaluation, including measurement of CSA at the level of the pisiform bone or tunnel inlet was performed at baseline and after 3months. A CSA threshold of more than 10mm2 was considered pathological.
CSA was increased in patients compared with controls (9.8±0.7mm2 vs 7.2±1.1mm2; P<0.001). Thyroxin substitution increased fT4 levels (baseline, 11.0±0.6pmol/L vs 15.5±0.4pmol/L; P<0.001) and decreased TSH (baseline, 23.9±6.0mIU/L vs 2.7±0.2mIU/L; P<0.001). Thyroxine treatment decreased CSA to 8.4mm2±0.3mm2 (P=0.033). Before treatment, four patients experienced distal paresthesia in the median nerve distribution area. Increased CSA pathognomonic for carpal tunnel syndrome found in two symptomatic patients normalized after 3months. No clinical symptoms were observed after 3months. A positive correlation was found between TSH and CSA (R=0.155, P=0.05) before treatment.
Our study demonstrates that increase in median nerve CSA caused by primary autoimmune hypothyroidism can be fully reversible after achieving target levels of TSH and fT4.
Thyroid hormones are involved in many functions of the central and peripheral nervous systems and, as a result, hypothyroidism may cause various neurological signs and symptoms (1). Chronic autoimmune thyroiditis is the most prevalent organ-specific autoimmune disease characterized by the presence of antibodies against thyroglobulin (anti-TG) and thyroid peroxidase (anti-TPO) (2). Autoimmune diseases have a broad spectrum of clinical manifestations. Among them, neurologic involvement, from both the central and the peripheral nervous systems, is one of the most challenging manifestations, regarding the diagnosis and treatment of autoimmune diseases (3). Several studies that have examined nerve conduction parameters in hypothyroid patients reported that deficiency of thyroid hormones causes motor neuropathy by affecting different peripheral nerves, but, more commonly, the median nerve (4, 5, 6). A number of retrospective studies reported the prevalence of neuropathy to be between 10 and 70% in patients with hypothyroidism (1, 7, 8, 9). The most common form of peripheral entrapment neuropathy is carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS) (10). According to the American Academy of Orthopedic Surgeons (AAOS), CTS is defined as a symptomatic median nerve compression neuropathy at the level of the wrist (11). The pathogenesis of abnormalities in peripheral nerves in patients with hypothyroidism include endoneurial accumulation of aminoglycane, as well as mucinous deposits in soft tissue surroundings of the peripheral nerves. These contribute to increased pressure on the median nerve at the wrist level (1, 9). Hypothyroidism produces alterations of fluid balance and peripheral tissue edema, which may lead to CTS development (1, 12). However, there are no data how autoimmunity plays a role in CTS pathogenesis. Consequently, treatment of hypothyroidism may help to minimize or cure CTS complaints (1, 12, 13, 14). Diagnosis is usually based on clinical symptoms and physical examination maneuvers, and is supported by nerve conduction studies (NCSs). In the literature review by the American Association of Neuromuscular and Electrodiagnostic Medicine (AANEM) on the diagnosis of CTS, the sensitivity and specificity of NCS was 85 and 95% respectively (15). Ultrasonography (US) has been used as an alternative to NCS in the diagnosis of CTS (16). Despite some limitations, US of median nerve has not only been considered for the diagnosis of CTS, but also for the identification of the severity of median nerve damage. In comparison with NCS, US measurements from different sites were most consistent, and best sensitivity and specificity was reported for measures of cross-sectional area (CSA) of median nerve at the level of os pisiforme (17). Various studies have demonstrated that CSA of the median nerve at the carpal tunnel inlet and carpal tunnel outlet is significantly greater in CTS patients than in the normal population (15, 18, 19, 20). The CSA of the median nerve at the carpal tunnel inlet (at the level of the pisiform) is the most sensitive and specific US finding in patients with CTS. The cut-off value of CSA at the tunnel inlet in patients with CTS ranges from 6.5 to 15mm2 (19, 20, 21, 22). This difference in the cut-off point values of the tunnel inlet is due to the heterogeneity of study designs, different sample sizes, patient’s characteristics and operator experience (21). Median nerve enlargement (CSA≥10mm2 at the level of the pisiform bone or tunnel inlet) is the most commonly used parameter to diagnose CTS on US, and sensitivity has been reported to be as high as 97.9% using this parameter (16). To our knowledge, there have been no studies performed investigating autoimmune hypothyroidism and CSA using US. This study aims to provide novel information concerning US evaluation of CTS.
The primary objective of the study was to assess median nerve entrapment in patients with newly diagnosed and untreated autoimmune hypothyroidism in comparison with healthy adults. Furthermore, we assessed changes in the CSA by US before and following thyroxine treatment.
Patients and methods
We performed a cross-sectional, prospective follow-up study on 30 consecutive patients newly diagnosed with primary autoimmune hypothyroidism at the 5th Department of Internal Medicine, Medical Faculty of Comenius University, University Hospital Bratislava. The control group comprised age-, sex-, and BMI (Body mass index)-matched healthy controls. The control subjects had no history of any thyroid disorders and had a normal serum TSH and free T4. The study protocol was approved by the ethics committee of the University Hospital Bratislava, and informed consent was obtained from all patients and controls according to the World Medical Association Declaration of Helsinki, revised in 2000, Edinburgh.
Inclusion criteria were as follows: newly diagnosed and untreated autoimmune hypothyroidism defined by thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH) levels greater than 4.78mIU/L and aTG plasma levels greater than 60kIU/L and/or aTPO plasma levels greater than 60kIU/L. No prior history or presence of any thyroid disorder or other conditions that may cause compressive neuropathy (e.g. diabetes mellitus, acromegaly, paraneoplastic, inflammation, alcoholism, liver and kidney disease, as well as mechanical overload) documented in patients cohort.
Laboratory investigations including complete blood count, serum glucose, creatinine, electrolytes, liver and kidney enzymes, vitamin B12 and folic acid were performed for all patients at baseline to eliminate other possible causes of neuropathy.
All patients received thyroxine treatment (mean: 83.5µg, range: 25–125µg) for hypothyroidism, and TSH and fT4 levels were monitored for 3months following baseline. Patients in control group underwent US evaluation at baseline and following 3months.
Thyroid function was assessed by measuring the concentration of TSH using a solid-phase, monoclonal antibody-labeled chemiluminescent immunoassay (CLIA) (ADVIA Centaur and ADVIA Centaur XP; Tarrytown, NY, interassay coefficient of variability (CV), 3.55–5.51%); fT4 using a solid-phase, polyclonal antibody-labeled CLIA (ADVIA Centaur and ADVIA Centaur XP; Tarrytown, NY, USA, interassay CV, 3.44–4.16%); thyroid peroxidase antibodies (TPO-Ab) using an electrochemiluminescence immunoassay (ECLIA) (Elecsys a cobas e analyzers, Basel, Swiss; interassay CV, 5.6–8.9%); and thyroglobulin antibodies (TG-Ab) using ECLIA (Elecsys and cobas e analyzers, Basel, Swiss; interassay CV, 5.8–6.0%).
All patients underwent high-resolution real-time US of the carpal tunnel before and after thyroxine therapy. Ultrasound measurements were performed by a single operator using a 12MHz linear array transducer (GE LOGIQ e portable ultrasound machine, Willowick, OH, USA). The US examination was performed with the patient seated in front of the sonographer, with the forearm resting on the table and the palm facing up in the neutral position. We performed transverse imaging of the median nerve for the area of the carpal tunnel inlet, which is defined as the proximal margin of the flexor retinaculum between the scaphoid tubercle and the pisiform bone. A longitudinal view was used to confirm the correct identification of the median nerve. The median nerve was observed on the screen as an oval or ellipsoid hypoechoic reticular area with a hyperechoic rim beneath the flexor retinaculum (19). The median nerve CSA was measured by the direct method (tracing method). Each measurement was performed five times. To prevent measurement error, the highest and lowest values were eliminated, and the remaining three measurements were averaged. This is the most extensive methodology for measuring the median nerve encountered among the studies (23).
Statistical analysis was performed using the statistics software SPSS version 19 (IBM SPSS Statistics, IBM). Categorical data were expressed as the mean±standard error of the mean (s.e.m.). Unpaired t-tests were performed for comparisons between the hypothyroidism subject and his/her control subject who was matched for age, sex and BMI. Paired t-test was used to compare baseline and post-treatment results in the hypothyroid group. Pearson correlation coefficients were calculated to analyze the correlation between TSH, thyroid autoantibodies and CSA of the nervus medianus.
Thirty patients were included in the study at baseline and comprised 22 women and 8 men. In the control group, 22 women and 8 men were included. The mean age of patients was 49.2years, and in the control group, 52.6years. No significant difference in sex, BMI and age was found between both the patient and control groups. Before thyroxine treatment, a significantly greater median nerve CSA of patients in comparison with controls (9.8±0.7mm2 vs 7.2±1.1mm2; P<0.001) was observed (Table 1). In patients cohort, CSA>11mm2 in four patients was recorded. Significant differences were found between TSH levels at baseline (23.9±6.0mIU/L) and after 3months (2.7±0.2mIU/L; P<0.001). In the cohort of patients, a number of 16 had TSH>10mIU/L and 14 patients had normal levels of fT4. In those 14 subjects, median nerve CSA was greater in comparison with controls (9.8±0.4mm2 vs 7.2±1.1mm2; P<0.001). In entire study group after thyroxine treatment, median nerve CSA significantly decreased (9.8±0.7mm2 vs 8.4±0.3mm2; P=0.033). After treatment, no difference in BMI was observed (24.5±0.8kg/m2 vs 24.4±0.7kg/m2) (Table 2). None of the patients had BMI>30kg/m2 at baseline and after treatment.
Baseline characteristics of patients and control groups. Data is presented as means or mean±s.e.m.
|Variable||Patients (n=30)||Control (n=30)||P-value|
Body-mass index, levels of thyroid-stimulating hormone and free thyroxine, and cross-sectional area before and after treatment with thyroxine. Data are presented as mean±s.e.m.
There was a relationship between hypothyroidism and median nerve CSA. At baseline, a positive correlation was observed between TSH and CSA (R=0.155, P=0.05) (Fig. 1), and a negative correlation was found between fT4 and CSA (R=−0.149, P=0.001) (Fig. 2). No correlation was observed between TSH, fT4 and CSA after normalization of thyroid function after 3months. This result was expected as a common physiological finding.
In four hypothyroid patients, clinical signs (e.g. distal paresthesias with weakness, tingling and pain in the distribution of the median nerve) of CTS were reported. Two of them had a baseline CSA measurement greater than 11mm2, which is considered pathognomonic for CTS. Following 3months of appropriate hormone replacement, CSA values were normalized in these patients, and their symptoms resolved.
Previous studies of ultrasound assessment of median nerve confirmed greater median nerve CSA in patients with thyroid dysfunction in comparison with healthy controls. However, no previous study on thyroid hormone replacement-mediated effect on CSA was reported.
In this study, we performed ultrasound measurement of the median nerve CSA in patients which are due to thyroid dysfunction at higher risk of developing CTS, followed by US measurements after 3-month thyroxine treatment. The strengths of the study are prospective study design of consecutively included hypothyroid patients with carefully matched control group and using of high-tech US performed by a single examiner. We are aware of some limitations e.g. smaller sample size with low number of patients with clinical signs of CTS and presence of subclinical hypothyroidism in some patients.
Recent studies have shown that US is effective in confirming the diagnosis of CTS (24, 25, 26). Ultrasound has several advantages compared with NCS. First, other lesions that display symptoms similar to CTS may be excluded from examination, and these include tenosynovitis, mass lesions and anatomic defects. Furthermore, US is cheaper, widely available, involves a short examination time and it is more sensitive and less invasive than NCS. The use of US can be recommended as the first-line method in the diagnosis of CTS (24).
In this study, all patients with hypothyroidism were found to have significantly higher TSH levels and lower fT4 levels compared with the control group. At baseline, US measurement of the CSA at the level of the pisiform bone demonstrated a mean value of 9.8mm2 in the patient group compared with 7.2mm2 in the control group, which is comparable to results from previous studies (15, 19, 25, 26, 27). In the study group, 14 patients had fT4 levels in normal range. Accumulation of mucopolysaccharides in the tendon sheaths and synovial membranes may cause CTS by loading pressure on the median nerve. It is obvious that this condition is more common in long-standing disease (28). Some studies have shown that the neuromuscular signs of hypothyroidism may be present in the subclinical forms as well (29, 30, 31). Despite this fact, a similar study by Jalilzadeh et al. indicated that there were no neuropathic or myopathic changes in patients with subclinical hypothyroidism, besides CTS (32). Study by Shiri using neuromuscular studies showed that symptoms of CTS are also seen in patients with hypothyroidism when they are euthyroid or they are on thyroid replacement therapy, but CTS was not a consequence of subclinical hypothyroidism (33). However, this study was aimed to detect the median nerve thickening measured by ultrasound regardless of clinical manifestation of thyroid disease or CTS. When statistical analysis was performed in subset of patients with normal fT4 levels and increased TSH, the results for median nerve CSA still remain significantly elevated in comparison with healthy controls.
Changes in the BMI may potentially affect the integrity of the nerve. Werner et al. demonstrated that obese individuals (BMI>29) are 2.5 times more likely to complain of CTS than slender individuals (BMI<20) (34). The correlation between the CSA of the median nerve with BMI may exist. In this study, no significant difference in BMI was observed between patients and the control group; hence, our results do not appear to be influenced by this factor.
In our patient cohort with hypothyroidism, the CSA of the median nerve was greater in men (10.3±0.4mm2) compared with women (9.7±0.5mm2). The CSA of the median nerve was greater in men compared with women in control group as well. This result is similar to the study of 49 patients, who reported the CSA of the median nerve proximal to the carpal tunnel to be 2.2mm2 higher in men than in women, although these patients did not have hypothyroidism (35).
To the best of our knowledge, there is no study comparing the effect of thyroxine treatment on the CSA in patients with primary hypothyroidism. We have performed a prospective follow-up study of patients treated with thyroxine over a 3-month period. The results confirmed a significant decrease in TSH levels and CSA values after thyroxine treatment, with no change in BMI. At baseline, a significant correlation was observed between TSH, fT4 levels and CSA values, although this relationship was not observed following normalization of TSH and fT4. This relationship confirmed that the CSA values in patients with overt hypothyroidism are directly influenced by levels of thyroid hormones.
Furthermore, at baseline, four patients were reported to have distal paresthesia in the distribution of median nerve, with weakness, tingling and pain. Pathologically increased median nerve CSA values (greater than 11mm2) were documented in two of these patients. At 3months, CSA values and clinical symptoms of CTS become normal in these four patients. This additional evaluation provides the opportunity to evaluate the efficacy of replacement therapy on the enlargement of the CSA of the median nerve, and aids in the prevention of unnecessary surgery in primary hypothyroidism patients with clinical signs of CTS. Follow-up of these patients demonstrated that the abnormalities related to entrapment neuropathy in hypothyroid patients can be reversed with adequate treatment.
This study demonstrated the influence of autoimmune hypothyroidism on structural alterations of the nerve, represented by US determinants of median nerve CSA, and thus evaluated the adverse effect of hypothyroidism on the median nerve. This study provides coherent data on the effect of primary hypothyroidism on the enlargement of the median nerve CSA. The data were evaluated with respect to median nerve CSA measurements and compared with BMI-, age- and sex-matched controls. Patients with untreated primary hypothyroidism were found to have a significantly greater CSA compared with healthy controls. In addition, the presence of entrapment neuropathy in hypothyroidism decreased after replacement treatment in newly diagnosed patients. The study provided a support to a well-known clinical observation that adequate treatment helps to prevent surgical decompression in CTS induced by hypothyroidism. Early treatment of hypothyroidism may impede the progression of neuromuscular complications or minimize their occurrence. Autoimmunity may potentially play an important role in the pathogenesis of nerve thickening associated with hypothyroidism; however, this has not yet been investigated. Ultrasound is a sensitive, noninvasive method for the diagnosis of CTS associated with hypothyroidism providing a metric which improves with substitution treatment of hypothyroidism, thus supporting the pathophysiology and clinical findings.
Declaration of interest
The authors declare that there is no conflict of interest that could be perceived as prejudicing the impartiality of the research reported.
This research did not receive any specific grant from any funding agency in the public, commercial or not-for-profit sector.
The authors would like to acknowledge Dr Michal Chovanec for critical input during manuscript writing.
KasemAAFathySMShahinDAFikryAA. Carpal tunnel syndrome in hypothyroid patients: the effect of hormone replacement therapy. American Journal of Internal Medicine2014254–58. (doi:10.11648/j.ajim.20140203.14)
LazúrováIBenhatchiKRovenskýJKozákováDWagnerováHTajtákováMShoenfeldYMacejovaZ. Autoimmune thyroid disease and autoimmune rheumatic disorders: a two-sided analysis. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences20091173211–216. (doi:10.1111/j.1749-6632.2009.04809.x)
AppenzellerSShoenfeldYde CarvalhoJF. Neurologic manifestation of autoimmune diseases. Autoimmune Diseases20122012683212. (doi:10.1155/2012/683212)
YeasminSBegumNBegumSRahmanSMH. Relationships of nerve conduction parameters with the thyroid hormones in hypothyroid patients. Journal of Bangladesh Society of Physiologist201381–5. (doi:10.3329/jbsp.v8i1.16638)
EslamianFBahramiAAghamohammadzadehNNiafarMSalekzamaniYBehkamradK. Electrophysiologic changes in patients with untreated primary hypothyroidism. Journal of Clinical Neurophysiology201128323–328. (doi:10.1097/WNP.0b013e31821c30d9)
DijkMAJReitsmaJBFischerJCSandersGTB. Indications for requesting laboratory tests for concurrent diseases in patients with carpal tunnel syndrome: a systematic review. Clinical Chemistry2003491437–1444. (doi:10.1373/49.9.1437)
El-SalemKAmmariF. Neurophysiological changes in neurologically asymptomatic hypothyroid patients: a prospective cohort study. Journal of Clinical Neurophysiology200623568–572. (doi:10.1097/01.wnp.0000231273.22681.0e)
DuyffRFVan den BoschJLamanDMvan LoonBJBLinssenWHJP. Neuromuscular findings in thyroid dysfunction: a prospective clinical and electrodiagnostic study. Journal of Neurology Neurosurgery and Psychiatry200068750–755. (doi:10.1136/jnnp.68.6.750)
AjeenaIM. Prevalence of neuromuscular abnormalities in newly diagnosed patients with thyroid dysfunction. American Journal of Research Communication2013179–88.
American Academy of Orthopedic Surgeons. Clinical practice guidelines on diagnosis of carpal tunnel syndrome. In American Academy of Orthopedic Surgeons edn 1 p 3. Rosemont, IL, USA2007.
KececiHDegirmeY. Hormone replacement therapy in hypothyroidism and nerve conduction study. Journal of Clinical Neurophysiology20063679–83. (doi:10.1016/j.neucli.2006.04.001)
PalumboCFSzaboRMOlmstedSL. The effects of hypothyroidism and thyroid replacement on the development of carpal tunnel syndrome. Journal of Hand Surgery200025734–739. (doi:10.1053/jhsu.2000.8642)
FathySMShahinDKasemAA. The effect of hormone replacement therapy in hypothyroid patients with carpal tunnel syndrome. Anveshana Ayurveda Medical Journal20108156–170.
ChanKYGeorgeJGohKJAhmadTS. Ultrasonography in the evaluation of carpal tunnel syndrome: diagnostic criteria and comparison with nerve conduction studies. Neurology Asia20111657–64.
McDonaghCAlexanderMKaneD. The role of ultrasound in the diagnosis and management of carpal tunnel syndrome: a new paradigm. Rheumatology2015549–19. (doi:10.1093/rheumatology/keu275)
El MiedanyYEl GaafaryMYoussefSAhmedINasrA. Ultrasound assessment of the median nerve: a biomarker that can help in setting a treat to target approach tailored for carpal tunnel syndrome patients. SpringerPlus201541–10. (doi:10.1186/2193-1801-4-1)
KwonBCHJungKBaekGH. Comparison of sonography and electrodiagnostic testing in the diagnosis of carpal tunnel syndrome. Journal of Hand Surgery200833A65–71. (doi:10.1016/j.jhsa.2007.10.014)
WangLYLeongCHPHuangYCHHungJWCheungSMPongYP. Best diagnostic criterion in high-resolution ultrasonography for carpal tunnel syndrome. Chang Gung Medical Journal200831469–476.
WongSMGriffithJFHuiACFTangAWongKS. Discriminatory sonographic criteria for the diagnosis of carpal tunnel syndrome. Arthritis and Rheumatology2002461914–1921. (doi:10.1002/art.10385)
SarrafPMalekMGhajarzadehMMiriSParhizgarERazaviSZE. The best cutoff point for median nerve cross sectional area at the level of carpal tunnel inlet. Acta Medica Iranica201452613–618.
FowlerJRGaughanJPIlyasAM. The sensitivity and specificity of ultrasound for the diagnosis of carpal tunnel syndrome: a meta-analysis. Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research20114691089–1094. (doi:10.1007/s11999-010-1637-5)
RollSCCase-SmithJEvansKD. Diagnostic accuracy of ultrasonography vs electromyography in carpal tunnel syndrome: systematic review of literature. Ultrasound in Meicine & Biology2011371539–1553. (doi:10.1016/j.ultrasmedbio.2011.06.011)
Ghasemi-radMNosairEVeghAMohammadiAAkkadALeshaEMohammadiMHSayedDDavarianAMaleki-MiyandoabTA handy review of carpal tunnel syndrome: from anatomy to diagnosis and treatment. World Journal of Radiology20146284–300. (doi:10.4329/wjr.v6.i6.284)
WongSMGriffithJFHuiACFKaiLo SFuMWongKS. Carpal tunnel syndrome: diagnostic usefulness of sonography. Radiology200423293–99. (doi:10.1148/radiol.2321030071)
El MiedanyYEAtySAAshourS. Ultrasonography versus nerve conduction study in patients with carpal tunnel syndrome: substantive or complementary tests?Rheumatology200443887–895. (doi:10.1093/rheumatology/keh190)
SwenWAJacobsJWBussemakerFEde WaardJWBijlsmaJW. Carpal tunnel sonography by the rheumatologist versus nerve conduction study by the neurologist. Journal of Rheumatology20012862–69.
AkarsuEOAcarHOzerFGünaydınSAkarsuÖÖzcanTAÖzbenSMutluABedirMGülGÇElectromyographic findings in overt hypothyroidism and subclinical hypothyroidism. Turkish Journal of Neurology201319128–133. (doi:10.4274/tnd.05658)
MonzaniFCaraccioNDel GuerraPCasolaroAFerranniniE. Neuromuscular symptoms and dysfunction in subclinical hypothyroid patients: beneficial effect of L-T4 replacement therapy. Clinical Endocrinology19992237–242. (doi:10.1046/j.1365-2265.1999.00790.x)
RazaSAMahmoodN. Subclinical hypothyroidism: controversies to consensus. Indian Journal of Endocrinology and Metabolism201317636–642. (doi:10.4103/2230-8210.123555)
JalilzadehSHBahramiAEftekharosadatB. Elektrophysiologic changes in patients with subclinical hypothyroidism (in Persian). Medical Journal of Tabriz University of Medical Sciences20072937–41.
WernerRAAlbersJWFranzblauAArmstrongTJ. The relationship between body mass index and the diagnosis of carpal tunnel syndrome. Muscle and Nerve199417632–636. (doi:10.1002/mus.v17:6)
KlauserASHalpernEJFaschingbauerRGuerraFMartinoliCGablMFAroraRBauerTSojerMLoscherWNBifid median nerve in carpal tunnel syndrome: assessment with US cross-sectional area measurement. Radiology2011259123–129.